“ Went here on 9/17/21 at 5pm with a friend. We decided on checking out the buffet. When we arrived we found they did have outside seating. The inside is big, a lot of room and clean. The staff was very nice and welcoming. There is a small bar area. They also have some tv’s on the walls. Since it was Friday I did see the buffet did have fish. Welcome to Wisconsin on a Friday night! They also had some shrimp. The shrimp was great. They have a nice selection at the salad bar. I recommend the stuffed mushrooms. They were out of this world! I had a few slices of the pizza and it was good. Next time I plan to dine in. I want to just order up a pizza. The buffet was very good. Friday nights it runs from 5-8pm. Until the next review, Steve-O, out! ”

“ My family has ordered takeout from here for many years and always have a good experience. The workers up front are never afraid to have a conversation. The pizza here doesn't compare to any other local chains. And the environment is always very enjoyable. I recommend coming here. ”

“ First time visiting your restaurant. Loved everything about it! Atmosphere, very friendly staff, nice bar, great seating, clean bathrooms thank you for that . We were there for lunch buffet can I just say thank you for taking pride in your food. Everything was awesome, great tasting, love the variety! Great salad bar to! If I could give 10 stars I would. We will definitely be back! ”

“ Located right next to a brewery, this spot is hard to beat! The quality is top-notch, and the restaurant’s warm and inviting atmosphere makes it even better. The service is consistently excellent, and the convenience of being able to walk your pizza over to the brewery is simply fantastic. It’s the best of both worlds. ”

“ Love this one better than the west side one. Why I order from here and pick up from East side. Bad experience on the West side one. Their Philly sandwiches are like the Chicago beefs are amazing, along with their pizzas! Definitely recommend this one on the East side. And I live on the West side and will travel to this one. ”

“ Loved the Pizza buffet that has a large variety. Chicken wings boneless and regular, salad cookies, pasta, Italian beef sandwich and more. Limited hours so check before you go. Pizza was excellent too. Small restaurant with ample seating. Not fine dining so rating based on type and style of restaurant ”

“ Makayla was very attentive and quick to answer any questions we had. The food was warm and arrived promptly. We got the cheese curds, Gallagher bread, bread sticks, Chicken Alfredo pizza, and a deep dish pepperoni pizza. The cheese, as you would expect, was incredible and the sauce was very traditional tasting. Toppings were quality and it didn’t seem like they cut corners anywhere when it comes to their pizza! The environment of the restaurant was very clean and traditional feeling. Being located next to a brewery allowed a large selection for alcohol. Our experience at Gallagher was great and we would definitely be back! ”

“ A restaurant that has it all! The pizza is hands down delicious, this is a known fact and what they are known for! Not greasy, perfect crust. Pictured is a pizza our son likes - pineapple, Canadian bacon and olives. Signature pizzas are fantastic too - Mediterranean is my absolute fav. They have so much more! Appetizers (supreme combo basket is our go to), salads, ribs! Perch! Many pasta dishes, sandwiches/subs, kids menu and let’s not forget dessert of cheesecake and cookies! Staff is friendly and attentive. We have been lucky to have had Clara a few times - fantastic service! There is something for everyone. Always a positive experience and tasty food. Hits the spot every time. ”